featured are record player needles universal

So, are record player needles universal? Yes and no. While any record player needle will work to convert vibrations created by groove shape into sound, the best needles are durable (either nude diamond or diamond tipped), small, and have a large surface area. Vinyl and shellac both use grooves to record audio, so most cartridges will work. But they aren’t created equally.


Introduction

To answer the question “are record player needles universal,” it’s important to understand what it is a needle does. The sound of a record is stored in the grooves running around its surface. As the needle of a record player runs through those grooves, it picks up vibrations within the grooves that will be converted into electrical signals, and these signals become music.

While any needle made for a record player can perform this task, some do so better than others. When deciding if a needle is right for you, it’s important to consider a needle’s composition, size, and shape.

If a stylus is soft, damaged, or too large, there’s a good chance you’re wearing down your records. It’s also important to know what your records are made of, as this can also affect what needle is right for you.


What Is A Record Player Stylus Made Of?

Record player needles manufactured after 1970 tend to be made of one standard (and therefore, universal) material, diamond. Diamond is exceptionally hard, and though this sounds like a recipe for scratches and cracks, harder needles are actually safer for your records.

While a hard material will maintain its shape with minimal deterioration, soft materials will quickly break down and load the grooves of a record with abrasive materials, wearing down both the record and the needle itself faster.

When selecting a diamond needle, you’ll have two options: “nude” and “tipped.” A nude stylus is made of solid diamond and will be more expensive than the diamond-capped metal of a tipped stylus. Though a tipped needle will still be durable, the metal will add mass to the stylus overall, which can affect the reproduction of sound and impair tracking.

While diamond is the standard for today’s styluses, you may find yourself in possession of a vintage player, and with it a vintage stylus. These players did not utilize just one standard material, but often employed osmium or sapphire needles. Crystals like sapphire are somewhat more durable than osmium, but neither is ideal for protecting your records from damage. If you’re looking for a “universal needle,” start by narrowing your search to diamond.


Stylus Shape and Size

Selecting the shape and size of your needle is where you’ll find the most variation in sound fidelity, price, and durability across the market. While size is an easy black-and-white matter (the smaller the needle, the better it will fit the grooves of a record) there are benefits and drawbacks to every shape available, and no one shape will be the perfect match for everyone.

chart record player needle shapes and sizes

Spherical/Conical: If your main concern is price, you’ll want to get a spherical (or conical) stylus. These styluses resemble the tip of a ballpoint pen and have a large radius. While this large radius doesn’t trace higher frequencies well, the effect it has on the record itself is debated. Some claim that a conical needle wears down a record more quickly, but evidence from electron microscopes indicates that the shape may in fact be easiest on the record so long as the tracking is light.

Elliptical/Bi-Radial: After conical, elliptical (or bi-radial) needles are the most used in record players. The elliptical shape provides more surface area for the record to make contact, and this in turn provides more accurate tracking of high frequencies. The downside to this, however, is that, despite the slightly higher price tag, an elliptical needle will wear down more quickly than a spherical one.

Hyperelliptical/ Shibata/ Fine Line/ Stereohedron: The many-named next-evolution of the elliptical needle, hyperelliptical styluses provide excellent high-frequency performance, more durability, better tracking, and less record wear when properly aligned. These needles are more difficult to manufacture (and so come at a higher price) but you’ll likely see a longer lifespan than you would from its cheaper predecessor.

Micro-Line: Microridge needles are the newest frontier in player styluses, designed by computers to more accurately match the tools used to cut records. This shape-matching leads to the best available high-frequency performance and a longer life for both record and stylus when properly aligned. These needles have a multi-level ridge shape that is far more complex than any needle we’ve previously discussed, as well as the highest price tag.


Vinyl vs Shellac

Chances are, if you’re investing in a nice needle, you want to maintain it for as long possible. While stylus types are the focus of this article, the composition of the record itself is important to note, both for its own health and the health of the needle.

Vinyl: Vinyl has been the preferred material for records since the late 1930s. Unless your collection boasts records produced before the year 1950 it’s almost guaranteed your discography is pressed entirely on vinyl. Vinyl comes in both standard and microgroove formats, and this is where the durability of your stylus comes into play. Microgroove records have demonstrated a tendency to wear down a stylus more quickly than standard grooves, which in turn affects the sound fidelity of your player.

Shellac: Shellac has been in rotation since 1895 and was still used in record production in some parts of the world until the 1960s. Shellac is thicker and less flexible than vinyl, and the larger records would often shatter if dropped or bent though the paper label would often hold the pieces together and keep the record playable.

Playing these shattered records will result in loud pops as the needle runs over the cracks (this, in turn, will often lead the needle itself to break, which would demand a replacement of both record and stylus). Shellac records, due to their structure, can only hold so many grooves per inch, and will never be microgroove formatted, which, as previously mentioned, plays a part in the health of your stylus.


Conclusion

So, are record player needles universal? Yes and no. While any record player needle will work to convert vibrations created by groove shape into sound, the best needles are durable (either nude diamond or diamond tipped), small, and have a large surface area. Vinyl and shellac both use grooves to record audio, so most cartridges will work. But they aren’t created equally.

Hopefully this has given you the information you were looking for. If you liked this educational article then check out my other ones. If you’re interested in buying an affordable record player then check out my top list on that.


References

  1. http://www.aes.org/aeshc/pdf/how.the.aes.began/marcus_the-diamond-stylus.pdf

Categories:

Tags:

2 Responses

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to the newsletter